Where: Dahlonega, Georgia Style: Eastlake home, country interior Tea Selection: 10+ loose leaf teas by local tea blender Tea Rabbit’s Teas Teatimes: Thursday to Sunday, 11 or 1:30 Reservations: Reservations highly recommended Contact: 706-509-9024 Cost: $49.99 A Dickens’ Christmas Tea; $34.99 Afternoon Tea; $29.99 Children’s Tea (ages 12 and under); $16.99 Cream Tea Destination Tea Tips: Leave time to shop Dahlonega’s historic square, just a block away, with: numerous antique stores (great teacup finds at No. 3 Vintage), Waffle’s sister store for anglophiles – the Crown & Bear gift shop, and Tea Rabbit’s for magical gifts and oodles of original loose leaf tea blends.
Destination Tea Notes: At Destination Tea, we dream of a teahouse for every historic downtown, and so were very pleased to learn that British expat Fiona Bagley was opening a tearoom in downtown Dahlonega last year. Fittingly, the tearoom is named after daughter Katz’ Corgi — a favorite breed of the British royal family — Sir Waffle Dean McWaffleburg Wigglebum. After the Dahlonega Downtown Development Authority beautifully restored the 1909 Head House, they chose the Bagleys’ tearoom for their first floor tenant. The charmingly appointed tearoom is not the only loveliness here. Tea is served using the Bagleys’ teapots, collected over twenty years, including vintage beauties you may have never seen before. We loved finding locally blended teas on the menu, and most enjoyed the savories. Food manager Missy shared her evolving plans to make this afternoon tea as homemade as possible in a tearoom with no oven. (During the house’s redevelopment, the former kitchen’s restaurant equipment was actually removed.) Pre-made scones are imported, while desserts are outsourced, save a homemade treat: Fiona’s 300-year-old syllabub recipe (which she gave us permission to share with you). The friendly and attentive customer service here makes Waffle’s the perfect place to rest a spell and charge your batteries during an afternoon on the square.
The beautifully refurbished Victorian home lends its first floor to the tearoom.
The main dining rooms at the front of house
Tea for two by the front window
Also would love to sit next to the fireplace mantle
Farmhouse style seating is accented in dusty blues and soft white.
A portrait of the tearoom’s mascot Waffle overlooks the back room where a larger party has more privacy.
Admiring this vintage brass floor lamp
Tea Selection
We notice these little touches: the personal welcome, fresh hydrangeas, mini lemon wedges with tongs.
An added pleasure on our return visit: strawberry infused water
We begin by selecting two teas which we were invited to switch out later in the meal. We tried Tea Rabbits, Memento Mori, Orange Creamsicle and Countess Grey.
A new tea list on our return visit gives us more teas to explore. We love the playful creativity of Tea Rabbits’ blends. As we had a UNG student in our party, it was especially fitting to find a UniversiTea blend on the menu. We chose the Bridgerton, Lemon Meringue Pie, Vintage Gypsy and Georgia on my Mind teas.
The proper hostess, Fiona kindly pours our first cups while we comment on her pretty teapots.
As we were sharing two pots between four guests, it was not as much of a concern that the tea leaves remain in the pots, but the final pours were partially bitter. We prefer that teas are decanted in the kitchen, though some tea-goers enjoy the ritual of using the individual tea strainers, covering any oversteeped taste with plenty of milk and sugar.
On our return visit, we noted that tea leaves are still left in the generous teapots brought to the table. As you know, we like teas to be decanted before serving, to prevent oversteeping.
Scones & Spreads, Savories and Sweets
Tiered trays arrive, each serving an afternoon tea for two.
We were happy with every bite of the savory course: cream cheese and cucumber finger sandwich; Missy’s famous chicken salad, coronation egg (rather than the traditional coronation chicken), and the table favorite — roast beef with horseradish on a toasted round.
On our return visit, The Prince Harry pinwheel with carrot, cheese and onion was delightful, and the soft roll with roast beef and horseradish was equally tasty. Cucumber finger sandwiches round out the course, each item offered in double portions.
Fruit scones were served with jam, clotted cream and lemon curd. Perhaps they would have broken apart more easily for spreading if they had been warmer or less dense.
Dublin scones are reminiscent of an irish soda bread, with a dense, dry crumb. We like the authentic clotted cream, lemon curd and black currant jam that accompanies this course.
Commercial desserts such as cream puffs, macarons, petit fours and mini cakes could not delight us the way the tearoom’s homemade syllabub did. The tearoom could level up this course perhaps by working with a local baker.
A sweet rendering of the tearoom, including its mascot
Making a 16th Century British Dessert: Syllabub
Fiona Bagley’s recipe for Lemon Syllabub (thank you, Fiona!)
Serves 2
2 cups Heavy Whipping Cream
1 cup Sugar
1/2 tsp. Nutmeg
1/2 cup White Wine
1/4 cup Fresh Lemon Juice
1 Lemon, zested
1 Lemon Wafer
In chilled stainless steel bowl, beat cream, sugar and nutmeg until stiff peaks form. Whisk in wine, lemon juice and lemon zest. Freeze for at least 30 minutes. Serve in chilled glasses, top with wafer.
Just a sampling of the British goods for sale in Crown & Bear around the corner.
Tea hats and fascinators in a trunk on the wrap-around porch invite guests to accessorize for afternoon tea.
A nod to Waffle the Corgi, as you enter his tearoom.
We love comments! Destination Tea's comment policy shares a guiding principle with afternoon tea etiquette: please be gracious. We welcome honest comments that are not rude or scathing.